Amstrad Action


The Tolkien Trilogy

Author: The Balrog
Publisher: Beau Jolly
Machine: Amstrad CPC464

 
Published in Amstrad Action #52

The Tolkien Trilogy

Adventure compilations are rare things - especially good ones - so it is good to see that Beau Jolly is re-releasing The Hobbit, Lord Of The Rings and Shadows Of Mordor in one pack.

Many adventures have a Tolkienesque flavour, so it was inevitable that the most famous fantasy novel of all would turn up on computer. For those of you who have never heard of these games (where have you been all this time?), they take place in the world of Middle Earth, immortalised by JRR Tolkien in his various books. Each of the games is a 'classic' in computer gaming; The Hobbit as it was one of the first with graphics and interactive characters who acted intelligently (most of the time); Lord Of The Rings for the sheer size and complexity attempted for a tape-based game (and of course for its bugs) and Shadows Of Mordor because, again, of its size and complexity (and fewer bugs!)

All the games are now quite old (over two years) but the magic is still there, especially for readers of Tolkien. (If you haven't escaped from the Goblin's dungeon, you haven't lived!) The Hobbit is limited by today's standards but The Lord Of The Rings and Shadows Of Mordor have some impressive features even now, such as complex character interaction, large vocabulary, independent characters, and complex parsing together with over 200 locations in each. They also feature the ability to 'become' different characters (such as Frodo and Sam) to complete the game.

Because of these advanced features, Lord Of The Rings especially is very slow... Picking up an object can take ten seconds and moving locations twenty! Thus great patience is needed to complete the game. Another feature of LOTR (and also The Hobbit and Shadows Of Mordor to a lesser extent) is the bugs in the games. In fact bug-hunting in LOTR became for some, a hobby - the game has so many!

In conclusion, there's no doubt that LOTR is seriously bugged in places, but all three games are challenging and I enjoyed them very much (especially because I make a star appearance in the Lord Of The Rings).

If you haven't got them, and Scapeghost doesn't appeal to you, don't think twice - buy 'em!

Verdict

Atmosphere 87%
Interaction 84%
Challenge 80%
Overall 85%

The Balrog

Other Amstrad CPC464 Game Reviews By The Balrog


  • Scapeghost Front Cover
    Scapeghost
  • The Last Days Of Doom Front Cover
    The Last Days Of Doom
  • Classic Adventure Front Cover
    Classic Adventure
  • Panic Beneath The Sea Front Cover
    Panic Beneath The Sea
  • The Spiro Legacy Front Cover
    The Spiro Legacy
  • Scull PD Disc #15 Front Cover
    Scull PD Disc #15
  • Flook Front Cover
    Flook
  • Avon And Murdac Front Cover
    Avon And Murdac
  • Jaws: The Last Studhorse Front Cover
    Jaws: The Last Studhorse
  • The Smirking Horror Front Cover
    The Smirking Horror