Mutant Football League really impressed me. I'm a big football fan, but I do think non-fans would have fun with it too. I haven't seen character like this in a parody game in many years.

Nit-picky things aside, you end up with a game that plays easier than Madden, is downright hilarious, and won't break the bank to purchase. It really could use a full set of teams (then maybe some fake ones) and players that can speak English, but it doesn't take long for the game to remind you why you are playing in the first place – to kick the snot out of your opponent by any means necessary.