Future Publishing


ESPN NFL 2K5

Author: Leon Hurley
Publisher: Sega
Machine: PlayStation 2 (US Version)

 
Published in Official UK PlayStation 2 Magazine #56

SNAO (Sports Name Acronym Overload)

ESPN NFL 2K5

With two American football titles featuring in one issue the four readers who actually understand it all are spoilt for choice this month. Maybe there's a hidden American football underground over here somewhere, buying the games and secretly plotting a national sports coup. And this effort from Sega is defiantly one for the purists - managing to place itself somewhere above chess and slightly below global politics in terms of complexity.

ESPN NFL also has two of the most pointless modes for any sports event: The Crib and First-Person Football. The Crib is a virtual home that enables you to display the trappings of your success, and yes, that's about as thrilling as it sounds. But First-Person Football has to be the weirdest addition we've ever seen - if you thought it was hard to play from a bird's-eye view, try taking in the action from the inside of a helmet. Run through a crowded town centre while squinting for a rough idea of the effect.

This is simulation rather than entertainment. The various menus and buttons will reduce all but the bravest to tears as they try to separate their Dukes from their Strong Fan Iso. Not only is the level of depth daunting, the stop-start nature of play prevents any real excitement from building. It may be an accurate representation of the sport but then look how successful that's been over here.

Verdict

Graphics 50%
Adequate but uninspiring.

Sound 60%
Good commentary, droning crowds.

Gameplay 40%
Stilted and intermittent.

Lifespan 50%
Complex and unrewarding.

Overall 50%
ESPN provides a complex and bewildering level of authenticity. Only hardcore fans should approach the ten-yard line.

Leon Hurley

Other PlayStation 2 Game Reviews By Leon Hurley


  • EyeToy Kinetic Front Cover
    EyeToy Kinetic
  • Tak 2: The Staff Of Dreams Front Cover
    Tak 2: The Staff Of Dreams
  • Trivial Pursuit Unhinged Front Cover
    Trivial Pursuit Unhinged
  • Samurai Western Front Cover
    Samurai Western
  • Wild Water Adrenaline Featuring Salomon Front Cover
    Wild Water Adrenaline Featuring Salomon
  • Robots Front Cover
    Robots
  • Cold Winter (Spanish Version) Front Cover
    Cold Winter (Spanish Version)
  • Astro Boy Front Cover
    Astro Boy
  • Operation Air Assault Front Cover
    Operation Air Assault
  • Tenchu: Fatal Shadows Front Cover
    Tenchu: Fatal Shadows