Zzap


On-Field Football

Author: BW
Publisher: Activision
Machine: Commodore 64

 
Published in Zzap #2

American simulation: complex tactics, crunching tackles

On-Field Football

American Football is the game in question, and this simulation if for two players or one against the computer. Instead of the normal eleven players you only have four a side, but this is about all you can control.

To start with you choose a quarterback, wide receiver and tight end from the two of each on offer. These have different characteristics and your choice will affect the type of plays you should use.

Once your team is chosen and you've selected the length of the four quarters, you can get into the action. You start with the kick-off and from there on the offence (attacking team) always faces up the screen. If you are receiving the kick, a player will automatically catch the ball and you then control him to run back down the field, while the computer controls your other men.

On-Field Football

You will be tackled and two bodies will splat audibly to the turf. You will now have possession and you can try to move the ball upfield. You're trying to score points by getting a touchdown (like a try in rugby) worth 6, a fieldgoal (like a penalty or drop goal) worth 3 or a safety worth 2. You can do this through a series of running and passing plays.

Progress is made in ten-yard sections and you have four attempts or 'downs' to get more than ten yards - if you make it, you get another four attempts. There is a pause before each down, when the teams go into separate huddles to decide their next move. You must have the play called and executed before a thirty second clock expires.

Once the play is underway, you control the quarterback - the other players will run their set routes and you have to time when to throw the ball, or whether to run with it instead. A pass will give you control of the intended receiver who must move to catch the ball (you hope) and run upfield with it.

Eventually, you hope to get the ball into the opponents' end-zone for a touchdown and the one point kick that follows.

You can relieve tired players at the end of the third quarter (there are four), and you also have three timeouts per half to stop the game clock.

The player graphics are fairly simple on the all-green screen and there is only the occasional start, finish and scoreboard tune to add to the tackle sound effect.

BW

At first I found the game disappointing, because I was only playing against the predictable computer. Once you gain reasonable control over your plays, a different set of tactics and enjoyment reveal themselves. Non-fanatics probably won't like the game because they'll have to learn too many complicated rules, but two football fans playing against each other should find it very enjoyable. Certainly one worth persisting with.

GP

I don't know too much about American Football, and I found this a difficult game to get into. By removing the game's violence and adding some complex control, what do you end up with... a fairly boring sports simulation.

Planning Your Plays

The offensive and defensive plays are fairly complicated at first, and will take a lot of practice to get used to. They differ according to whether you're attacking or defending, and involve choosing one of several types of play and then giving specific instructions to each player.

The patterns that the players run are detailed in the instructions, and once you've learnt them you may be able to come up with quite complicated plays.

The diagrams and joystick controls will at first appear very confusing, but perseverance will reveal that the action is in fact fairly straightforward.

Once you've found a successful play against the computer, you can simply keep repeating it - something of a flaw in the game design. However, human opponents will prove more unpredictable.

Verdict

Presentation 78%
Good instructions with clear diagrams, but heavy going for the beginner.

Originality 73%
First attempt at a full simulation.

Graphics 52%
Chunky sprites which occasionally pass through each other.

Hookability 37%
Difficult rules and control are off-putting.

Sound 55%
Great splat tackle noise plus touchdown and title tunes.

Lastability 71%
For the enthusiast it presents an admirable lasting challenge.

Value For Money 62%
The enthusiast will like it but not any many others will.

Overall 61%

BW

Other Commodore 64 Game Reviews By BW


  • Tim Love's Cricket Front Cover
    Tim Love's Cricket
  • Ice Hunter Front Cover
    Ice Hunter
  • Felix In The Factory Front Cover
    Felix In The Factory
  • Cybertron Mission Front Cover
    Cybertron Mission
  • Whirlinurd Front Cover
    Whirlinurd
  • Battle For Normandy Front Cover
    Battle For Normandy
  • Up 'N Down Front Cover
    Up 'N Down
  • Richard Petty's Talladega Front Cover
    Richard Petty's Talladega
  • Combat Leader Front Cover
    Combat Leader
  • Ice Palace Front Cover
    Ice Palace