Your Sinclair


Cricket Captain

Author: Marcus Berkmann
Publisher: D&H Games
Machine: Spectrum 48K/128K

 
Published in Your Sinclair #52

Cricket Captain

This, though, is another kettle of halibut entirely. Whole Grand Prix is broadly accurate (or at least accurate enough to stop you blanching at every inaccuracy), Cricket Captain is all over the place. It's pretty clear here that no-one knows too much about the game beyond the most basic there's-this-geezer-with-the-ball. Otherwise how could you explain the way the best bowlers are always the best batsmen, something that doesn't happen more than once a generation in real life? In choosing the statistics to hone in on, the writers have fundamentally misunderstood the appeal of cricket, and perhaps more important the appeal of the statistics themselves. The whole notion of the 'transfer market' too is completely inaccurate. And most frustrating of all, each team is full of those randomly generated names we all remember from Football Director II - W Bukby, J Lijten and so forth. I recognise that it's probably harder to do a decent cricket sim than any other - no-one has come even close on any computer - but this is well below D&H's usual high standards.

Ridiculously poor - programmed by people who haven't a clue what they're talking about.

Marcus Berkmann

Other Spectrum 48K Game Reviews By Marcus Berkmann


  • Gunrunner Front Cover
    Gunrunner
  • Trivial Pursuit: Baby Boomer Edition Front Cover
    Trivial Pursuit: Baby Boomer Edition
  • Hydrofool Front Cover
    Hydrofool
  • Kosmos Front Cover
    Kosmos
  • BMX Simulator 2 Front Cover
    BMX Simulator 2
  • Athena Front Cover
    Athena
  • Joe Blade III Front Cover
    Joe Blade III
  • Samurai Front Cover
    Samurai
  • Ace Of Aces Front Cover
    Ace Of Aces
  • A Question Of Scruples Front Cover
    A Question Of Scruples