There's a pretty sizable discrepancy between what Manifold Garden achieves artistically, and what it achieves as a game. The latter is pretty forgettable, whereas the former occasionally borders on breathtaking. I leave it up to you how much weight you place on those two halves, but for me, it added up to a somewhat uneven whole.
Screenshots
Logout
Are you sure you want to logout?
Create Auction
If you auction an item, it will no longer show in the regular shop section of the site.